A toast to the loser in all of us!

March 30, 2011
Posted by

Recently I found myself at a cross-road.  For years I have made a mockery of the ‘entitlement’ sports fans believed they had over teams and players, only for myself to start believing the same thing…

I found three distinct groups when it comes to sport.  Those who play the game, those who write or comment about the game, and those who support the game.

At the best of times this is an uncomfortable marriage, but also a very necessary one.  All three groups believe they have certain ‘rights’, a right to privacy and the odd bad performance or dip in form (teams and players), a right to comment critically (media), and a right of entitlement and ownership (supporters).

All parties believe these rights have been earned, or deserved, but more importantly, that the other group needs to respect and acknowledge these rights over and above their own!

Inevitably, these groups or rather, mobs, gang up on one another, all believing they are entitled to answers or explanations especially when their rights have been violated.

A couple of recent examples highlighted this yet again for me.

Because of simple logistics, I am closer to the Stormers and Western Province rugby than any other rugby team in South Africa.  Through this I am privileged to receive information first-hand, or from the horse’s mouth so-to-speak.

I realised however over the weekend after the Stormers crushed the Western Force, followed by the article by Wentzel where Coetzee had the last laugh, that over the last 4 years just about every single article or column I wrote about this team was negative, and critical, or even overly-critical and unfair.

Wearing my media hat, I felt I had a right to criticise or report to the readers on matters which I believed they had a right to know.  But herein lies the problem.  These negative issues were issues perceived by one individual, or the media mob that attends every game and press conference at Newlands, and then literally force these views onto the public.

Never underestimate the power of the written word…  Unlike a conversation between individuals, what has been written does not have a tone, or a mannerism that can be associated to a feeling or interpretation.  It gets read, re-read, discussed, dissected, analysed and is effectively burnt into minds of those who choose to read it.

Another instance is Dewald Potgieter’s latest column on SuperRugby.  In his last 2 or 3 columns he has continually mentioned how the last couple of weeks has been the most difficult of his life.  How the expectation of the public is weighing heavily on his shoulders and how difficult he finds this, or provide answers to the fans and supporters.

In his latest edition, he tells a story of a man that walked up to him at a shop, the man told him that he thinks he is the most overrated player he has ever seen.  He explains his emotions in how he wanted to bang this guy’s head in, and the frustration he felt as a player, and how this man (who probably represented the U/19 F team) has no understanding for his position, and no respect for his ‘rights’.

Then at the same shop on a different day, a girl in the car-park screamed at him how he is her dad’s favourite player.

You can almost feel when reading his column the utter amazement, confusion and frustration the player had to go through or is going through.  You also almost feel sorry for him, as you would for Graeme Smith who fled to Ireland after the Cricket World Cup quarter final loss recently – but then you remember those losses…

This leads to my third example, Graeme Smith and the Proteas.

The media is in an absolute state of hysteria because Graeme Smith decided to take a break and head straight from India to Ireland to spent time with a loved one, and not come back to South Africa first to ‘answer to them’?

Entitlement anyone?

I can understand how the public (read media) is pissed off at the poor result against New Zealand, same as I am seemingly continually pissed off at WP Rugby for some unknown reason and the same reason that guy in the shop was pissed off at Dewald Potgieter.

We are frustrated, even hurt by the failures of people who essentially are, our heroes.  But since when are we entitled to answers?  Especially when there isn’t even a question to be asked?

I have sat in enough press conferences to tell you exactly what ‘questions’ Smith would have had to answer to;

“So Graeme, in your opinion what went wrong?”

We lost that’s what went wrong.

“Do you believe the chokers tag is justified?”

I have never seen a professional sports team go out with the intention to lose, but in sport, there is always a loser and this time it happened to be the Proteas.  You lose because you make mistakes, either individually or as a team, and more often than not in critical moments or more than the opposition.  That is the reality of sport, so in effect, every team that loses on any day, chokes.

Then there will be the usual questions about the team selections on the day, tactics used, etc., all very easy to criticise in hindsight.

So exactly what purpose would a Graeme Smith press conference have served?  Stroke the ego’s of the media perhaps?  Satisfy those millions out there who will suddenly say; ‘I told you so’?  All of whom were silent when the Proteas crushed India.

Fact is, everyone of the individuals discussed above need to realise that the job they chose, or the group they fall under, each comes with its own challenges and responsibilities.  Moreover, none of us are entitled to anything.

Each group needs the other, and the failures of one does not result in some form of victory for the other.  Understanding and respect will go a long way in getting the ‘answers’ we are all looking for when times are tough, perhaps that is worth remembering when your favourite player, or even least favourite player knock’s a ball in a critical moment, or spoons a catch to a fielder when it’s the last thing the team needed.

A sense of self-importance, often leads to delusions of grandeur.

To quote an advertisement currently on television; “Before you question the heart of a player, ask him what he wouldn’t give to have a second chance”.

Post to Twitter Post to Facebook Post to MySpace

Tags: , , , , ,

14 Comments

  1. avatar JT says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 10:55 am

    “I have never seen a professional sports team go out with the intention to lose, but in sport, there is always a loser”

    This is the crux of the matter IMO – Great article Thanks! :applause:

  2. avatar bryce_in_oz says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 12:24 pm

    Well written…

    As with any ‘job’… usually the higher the wages, the higher the stakes and the higher the risk…

    Pro sports takes this to another level when one adds the ‘fan’ and ‘celebrity’ factor…

    If you cannot stand the heat… get out of the kitchen…

  3. avatar Boertjie says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 5:45 pm

    Fact remains:
    Biff put his own pleasure ahead of leading the team back.
    When they needed him, he was absent, hiding away in a little love nest.
    That is not the sign of a true leader.
    You stick to your team through thick and thin, you don’t run and hide when the chips are down.

    I won’t lift a glass to toast this real loser.

    :Bakkies:

  4. avatar Morné says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 6:00 pm

    Reply to Boertjie @ 5:45 pm:

    AB also did not return with the team, they are staying abroad for tax reasons – perhaps we should be careful with assumptions too.

  5. avatar Boertjie says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 7:26 pm

    Tax reasons?
    How? What?

    If there is a lawful way to keep tax money that will be embezzled and wasted by the baboons running the country
    I may even applaud them.

  6. avatar Morné says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 7:32 pm

    Reply to Boertjie @ 7:26 pm:

    Hehe…

    I wasn’t aware of it either, only got told after writing the above.

  7. avatar DavidS says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 7:38 pm

    Chokers = losers = no toast from me

    But I won’t insult them or anything like that feeling an entitlement…

    Fact is I’ve become totally ambivalent towards cricket…

    Win or lose is immaterial to me…

    I simply vote with my pocket and television remote…

    As part of the Labour Court’s ordered restructure of Standard Bank to avoid retrenchments Standard has been forced to give up its ODI sponsorship…

    Local games are simply not attended and test matches are played to empty stadiums.

    ODI’s attract crowds and so do 20-20 games but no longer in the sellout numbers so reminiscent of the 1990′s when everyone detested the Springboks and slavishly wore light green “Prodya shuhts” and it was a bit backwards to speak Afrikaans in public in the “Wanda fihl rain buh nayshin of sthfricuh”

    But things changed…

    Nowadays nobody really supports cricket anymore..

    The alleged 26 million black fans they were going to generate never appeared…

    The team never changed its power base from an “upper class” game to an all inclusive one…

    Blacks kids want to be Ronaldhino… not Makhaya Ntini…

    And the whites they have so arrogantly shunted off in their quest for a racially balanced team are now wearing the shirts of other cricket playing countries… so the talent is gone… the fans are gone… and the new fan base never took its place and the new player base never happened….

    Now our white players represent other countries increasingly… and we will sink into the insignificant … in this respect cricket is a bit ahead of rugby in its collapse…

    England
    Australia
    New Zealand

    Heck even Canada and Ireland!

  8. avatar Morné says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 7:43 pm

    Reply to DavidS @ 7:38 pm:

    To be honest, since the advent of 20/20, my interest in cricket has all but disappeared…

  9. avatar the cheetahs are pumas! says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 8:19 pm

    hell we used to drive all over to watch the Freestate play cricket games! Now we dont even know when they are playing?

    But rugby with its collapsing scrums, 1000 penalties for ‘sealing’, hands in ruck and all kinds of kak that simply does not matter is going the same way.

    I used to think a rugby game between SA and NZ is my idea of heaven. Now I switch during the game to see if there are nice songs MTV.

    but who cares right…

  10. avatar DavidS says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 8:20 pm

    Joburg newspaper The Citizen reporting Biff resigned as skipper..

  11. avatar the cheetahs are pumas! says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 8:24 pm

    Reply to DavidS @ 8:20 pm:

    fok jou we get freestate version of The Citizen….

  12. avatar Boertjie says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 8:40 pm

    Reply to DavidS @ 8:20 pm:

    If that’s what they say it’s stale news.
    Or has he also resigned as test captain?

  13. avatar DavidS says:
    March 30th, 2011 at 10:06 pm

    Reply to Boertjie @ 8:40 pm:

    No idea

    It was on a billboard this aftyernoon I drove past so could be long past news… as I said cricket holds zero interest for me…

  14. avatar Morné says:
    March 31st, 2011 at 8:58 am

    Reply to DavidS @ 8:20 pm:

    He announced he will resign as skipper long before the World Cup.

Switch to our mobile site