Some interesting trends have emerged as we continue our statistics-based feature of the leading candidates for the Springbok No.10 jersey.
Tue, 10 Jul 2012 12:09
Sharks star Patrick Lambie did not play this past weekend (again), so we still have no stats to compare him with the other flyhalf candidates – incumbent Morné Steyn, Stormers pivot Peter Grant and Lions No.10 Elton Jantjies.
This past weekend the Bulls got hammered in Durban, the Stormers couldn’t score tries in the rain in Bloemfontein and the Lions entertained with a rare win in Johannesburg.
However, that has done nothing to change the perceptions many pundits have of strengths and weaknesses of the trio.
The facts, or stats, continue to tell a story of their own.
For one, Steyn and Jantjies both got more distance with their kicks out of hand at the coast than Grant did away from the coast, where the ball is meant to travel that much further.
The other perception is about Grant’s brilliant play – how well he ‘takes the ball to the line’ and creates opportunities. Yet, the Stormers’ only try this past weekend came from a Grant chip-kick (which does say something for his decision-making, of course).
And Jantjies has not had a single ‘try assist’ since we started monitoring these stats. Those assists came from players like Michael Bondesio, Anthonie Volminck and Lionel Mapoe.
We will let the numbers speak for themselves – again:
Morné Steyn (Bulls):
He is the Bok incumbent, has played 37 Tests and has 103 Super Rugby caps.
Played 59 minutes in the 40-24 demolition of the Cheetahs and the Bulls had a 40-0 lead when he left the field.
* Goal-kick success rate: 83.3 percent – five from six conversions.
* He received the ball 24 times – kicked nine times (for 401 metres gained – average distance of 44.5 metres per kick), passed 14 times, ran once and had one try-assist.
* He made five tackles and missed none.
Played 77 minutes in the 10-32 loss to the Sharks
* Goal-kick success rate: 100 percent – two from two (one conversion and one penalty)
* He received the ball 29 times – kicked six times (for 217 metres gained – average distance of 36.16 metres per kick), passed 21 times, ran twice and had no try-assist.
* He made five tackles and missed two.
Total:
* Goal-kick success rate: 88 percent – seven from eight
* He received the ball 53 times – kicked 15 times (for 618 metres gained – average distance of 41.2 metres per kick), passed 35 times, ran three and had one try-assist.
* He made 10 tackles and missed three.
Peter Grant (Stormers):
He has five Test caps, but has not played in Green & Gold since 2008. He has 83 Super Rugby caps.
He played all 80 minutes in the 27-17 win over the Lions.
* Goal-kick success rate: 100 percent – three from three conversion and two from two penalty goals.
* He received the ball 39 times – kicked twice (for 51 metres gained – average of 25.5 metres per kick), passed 32 times, ran five times and had one try-assist.
* He made eight tackles and missed two.
Played 80 minutes in the 13-6 win over the Cheetahs
* Goal-kick success rate: 100 percent – three from three (one conversion and two penalties)
* He received the ball 41 times – kicked 19 times (for 623 metres gained – average distance of 32.78 metres per kick), passed 15 times, ran seven and had one try-assist.
* He made seven tackles and missed one.
Total:
* Goal-kick success rate: 100 percent – six from six
* He received the ball 80 times – kicked 21 times (for 674 metres gained – average distance of 32.09 metres per kick), passed 47 times, ran 12 and had two try-assists.
* He made 15 tackles and missed three.
Elton Jantjies (Lions):
He was a Springbok tourist for the year-end tour of Britain and Ireland in 2010 and also a member of the Bok squad for the series against England in 2012, but has yet to play a Test. He has 23 Super Rugby caps.
He played all 80 minutes of the Lions’ 17-27 loss to the Stormers.
* Goal-kick success rate: 75 percent – two from two conversions and one from two penalties.
* He received the ball 40 times – kicked eight times (for 258 metres gained – average of 32.25 metres per kick), passed 27 times, ran five times and had no try assists.
* He made 10 tackles and missed just one.
Played 80 minutes in the 37-32 win over the Rebels
* Goal-kick success rate: 100 percent – seven from seven (four conversions and three penalties)
* He received the ball 34 times – kicked 12 times (for 492 metres gained – average distance of 41 metres per kick), passed 17 times, ran five and had no try-assist.
* He made eight tackles and missed three.
Total:
* Goal-kick success rate: 91 percent – 10 from 11
* He received the ball 74 times – kicked 20 times (for 750 metres gained – average distance of 37.5 metres per kick), passed 44 times, ran 10 and had no try-assist.
* He made 18 tackles and missed four.
There you have it. Do the stats lie? Who would you say was the most influential flyhalf this week?
By Jan de Koning









July 11th, 2012 at 11:57 am
Conditions!!!!!!!!ON THE FIELD
July 11th, 2012 at 11:58 am
actually NOT EVEN WORTH COMMENTING ON
July 11th, 2012 at 12:57 pm
Reply to Jacques(Bunny) @ 11:58 am:
Stats have never been Jan’s strong-point… actually nor most the RSA journo’s/commentators…
July 11th, 2012 at 12:59 pm
Grant’s seasonal success rate is around
96%. Can’t beat that.
He also kicks long distances from hand,
not that accurate though.
The chip kick seems to be suddenly coming
into vogue again – even the planless Boks
used it 3 times in the second test.
Beats me how long it takes teams to work
their way around flat standing defense.
July 11th, 2012 at 1:45 pm
you know my take on Stats
in that SA v England test 1 – I did analysed Spies and he made 1.5 tackles but according to the stats on the net he made 9!?
Take it with a pinch of salt!
July 11th, 2012 at 2:04 pm
Stats for kicking at posts are the
only really reliable ones.
July 11th, 2012 at 2:28 pm
Story about our own Shields:
In Bethlehem in die Vrystaat is ’n rock-ster gebore, en sy liedjies het almal met ore, ’n hart en ’n halwe brein in die jaar 2012 van die absurditeit van ons aardse strewe na geld en mag oortuig.
Só sou ek graag my profiel van Brendon Shields wou begin, maar Brendon is (nog) nie ’n rock-ster nie, eerder ’n platsak sanger en liedjieskrywer, soos sy tong-in-die-kies-ballade “Rockstardom” te kenne gee:
Babe I checked the bank – we got
no money in it I’m not sure where
tomorrow’s dinner will come from
You and I and the children gonna
move in with my folks for a while
FULL STORY http://152.111.1.87/argief/berigte/dieburger/2012/02/04/BJ/5/4FebBrendon.html
July 11th, 2012 at 2:41 pm
Reply to Boertjie @ 2:28 pm:
July 12th, 2012 at 12:51 am
Reply to JT_BOKBEFOK! @ 1:45 pm: Victor was the stats king, all repect, but he had great stats, if he might not make the tackle he would not, when he hit the ruck it was like a wet argus but we could see him standing off. Due respect of course…
So why is Grant not in the Bok team ahead of both players?
July 12th, 2012 at 3:47 am
Reply to Kevin Rack @ 12:51 am:
Rubbish… did you have your eye’s closed all 2011?
Only Schalk Burger/Brussouw had and unsurpassed work-rate over the entire test and S15 season… I lost count the amount of try-saving and cover tackles Matfield made all across the paddock when others slipped up, the amount of rucks he hit, LO’s he pilfered and ground he covered… his stats were spot-on…
As for wet-argus… Rocky Elsom would disagree with you…
July 12th, 2012 at 7:12 pm
Morne Steyn is great at what he does, tactical kicks, bombs and kicking goals but lets be honest his game oustide of that is limited. If he didn’t play behind a dominant pack he would struggle. His kicking radar has been woefully off this year too. England wouldn’t have had a chance if Morne hadn’t missed so many kickable goals.
Many people have mentioned Pat Lambie as the long-term option and it’s hard to disagree.
I would quite like to see someone like Johan Goosen of the Cheetahs tried out at 10. With Francois Steyn at 12 and Pat Lambie at 15. That would challenge the opposition greatly.
July 12th, 2012 at 9:58 pm
If De Koning had a look at the overall stats from the entire S15 maybe he’d not be so keen to punt his apparent lovechild…
Grant has missed the most tackles of any South African player.
Second the idea that he has good kicking distance must be a fucking fantasy wet dream by a WP diehard…
I rate Grant and always have… BUT he has NEVER EVER had a distance boot on him… never ever…
July 13th, 2012 at 2:31 am
You want him to place his line kicks
like Naas Das did?