Always the victim, never the perpetrator: All Blacks must own their acts of violence



For two days the world waited for Andrew Hore, Steve Hansen, Richie McCaw, Steve Tew or even the bloke who carries the bags to apologise for the All Black hooker’s unprovoked assault on Bradley Davies.

November 28, 2012 – 12:55PM

Mark Reason


New video angle of Hore assault

Instead, New Zealand rugby appeared stuck on an endless loop of John Cage’s soundless epic. At the time of writing there had not been a solitary public note of regret.

Andrew Hore talks to All Blacks head coach Steve Hansen and assistant coach Ian Foster after the match.Andrew Hore talks to All Blacks head coach Steve Hansen and assistant coach Ian Foster after the match. Photo: Getty Images

Many good men and women in this country are ashamed of this craven refusal to say sorry, but they should not be surprised.

When Adam Thomson took it upon himself to stand on Scotland’s Alasdair Strokosch’s head, All Blacks rugby reached for the euphemism.

The old melon, the bonce and the noggin had all got a bit of a scrape but there was apparently no malice in Thomson’s calculated decision to stamp on another human being’s skull.

"What Hore did has got no place on a rugby field as far as I'm concerned, it was an absolute disgrace" ... Wales attack coach Rob Howley on Andrew Hore's attack on Bradley Davies, pictured.“What Hore did has got no place on a rugby field as far as I’m concerned, it was an absolute disgrace” … Wales attack coach Rob Howley on Andrew Hore’s attack on Bradley Davies. Photo: Getty Images

The real villain of the piece was a Welsh rugby writer called Stephen Jones and the real victim was New Zealand rugby, which again was the unfortunate casualty of a media beat-up.

You do wonder if New Zealand rugby will ever learn how decent society behaves. When Dean Greyling disgracefully assaulted McCaw, the Springboks leadership reacted immediately. Coach Heyneke Meyer publicly called the attack “unacceptable” and said: “I want to apologise to Richie McCaw.” Captain Jean de Villiers said: “We’ll never condone playing dirty” and promised to take action.

But all we have had out of Hansen so far is evasion. Initially Hansen wasn’t sure if Hore “clocked him but he certainly hooked him out”.

A little later he said: “It looked like he was trying to clean out the Welshman in front of him It’s unfortunate that it’s happened.” Then Hansen said: “I am just resigned to the fact that he will probably get cited . . . think they think we’re thugs or something but we don’t play differently to anyone else.”

We should be thankful that Hansen is no longer a policeman. He would have presumably let Charles Manson off with a caution.

The All Blacks coach, like many of his predecessors, clearly suffers from Arsene Wenger syndrome, an unfortunate irritation of the optic nerve that causes temporary blindness when watching your own team.

The world accepts that rugby has always had its thugs. Martin Johnson and Danny Grewcock got up to some revolting things on a rugby pitch and many of the English press excoriated those men and their actions. But the world does not accept the code of silence that has pervaded the All Blacks and a supine part of their media for far too long.

Many years ago Cyril Brownlie became the first man to be sent off in a rugby match.

The Welsh referee was considered the finest in the world and he had already issued three general warnings. He then saw Brownlie stamp on an opposition player’s leg off the ball and he sent him from the pitch.

The All Blacks manager of the time said the referee had “made a mistake” and “a grave injustice has been done to Brownlie”, an occurrence that “could not help the spirit of imperialism”.

New Zealand papers whinged about the sending-off then and they are still crying about it now. True to future form, Brownlie has somehow become the victim of his own violent action.

It is this reaction that continues to gall the rest of the world. The recent list of All Blacks shame is a long one – the Canterbury front row deliberately beating up the 71 Lions, John Ashworth tearing open JPR’s face with a double stamp, Richard Loe’s assault on Paul Carozza, Jamie Joseph wrecking Kyran Bracken’s ankle, Keven Mealamu and Tana Umaga smashing Brian O’Driscoll’s shoulder.

These acts are bad enough, and other nations have similar shameful incidents in their rugby history, but what really grates is the consistent lack of a full and proper apology.

Steve Hansen talks of taking ownership, but when has New Zealand rugby ever taken ownership of these acts of violence? These players are national folk heroes just like Colin Meads, the daddy of them all.

The national exculpation of Mealamu and Umaga was a disgrace that still angers many people in Britain and other parts of the rugby world. It was an assault that came desperately close to breaking a decent man’s neck.

And yet many in the New Zealand rugby community portrayed the All Blacks as the victims of an hysterical over-reaction by the British media.

If there was any hysteria, it was caused by shock at New Zealand’s collective failure to say sorry for what constituted common assault.

Good on the many callers in to talkback radio who have condemned Hore’s attack on Davies, but the delay in a similar condemnation from either the All Blacks management or the NZRU shows how out of touch these people still are.

The nation may be growing up, but New Zealand rugby is still behaving like the child who won’t own up.

How glorious it would be if Tew, Hansen, McCaw and Hore faced the world’s media and apologised to Bradley Davies.

How glorious it would be if Joseph was told to strip Hore of the captaincy of the Highlanders.

How glorious it would be if the law in this country decided to prosecute rugby players for assault.

Is that really all so far fetched? Together we could make it happen.

Fairfax NZ News

Poll: Have the All Blacks shown enough contrition for Andrew Hore’s hit?



Total votes: 5249.

Poll closes in 2 days.

Read more:

Facebook Comments


  1. Well they have get away with so much so far on the rugby field whats a little violence too.

    The AB’s are untouchable and very arrogant when it comes to trasngressions. If some player does it to the them they bleat and bleat like a mulesing sheep but as soon as the boot is on the other foot they say nothing or are even smug.

    This is a brillaint off the field strategy that allows players like McCaw to blantantly cheat, in fact the whole AB team seem to disregard the laws are throw tanties when penalised.

    Nonu is another player living on the edge of dirty play. I have seen him spear tackle players and not get cited. Does it have anything to do with Paddy.

    Yes it does have everything to do with Paddie as this a deliberate stratgey and it works. So well done on planning but crap for the game.

    Watch the game on the weekend and the AB will be break the laws more than England but will get away with most.

  2. I think the writer here has gone a bit hysterical but the All Blacks definitely get away with more stuff than most. Unfortunately I think it’s because they play such a nice brand of rugby that referees go a bit blind to all the holding on/lying all over the ball/hands on the ball.

    Hore should definitely have been red-carded in the first minute in the Wales game. Could have changed the result, but the way Wales are playing I somehow doubt it.

  3. Cheats yes, thugs I’m not so sure. What Hore did was thuggish but every country has those kind of players – although Bakkies was demonised by the rest of the world for everything he did, he did cross the line into mindless violence sometimes. I think he started to believe in the so-called “enforcer” tag too much by the end of his career and it’s a worry that Etzebeth has already picked up the monicker.
    On the subject of cheats, Hansen might say otherwise but you can’t tell me it’s not a team tactic to infringe at every ruck. They do it because star-struck refs let them get away with it.

  4. And maybe because star-struck refs
    apparently tries to assist the team
    that “wants to play rugby”?

    This is quite a damning article.

  5. They discussed this on ReUnion this week, and the panel was in agreement that the ABs need to condemn stuff like this much like Heyneke did with Greyling.

    So the NZ public are in agreement with the sentiment, much like most South Africans condemned Dean for the stuff he got up to.