Wilson: Ditching SA is madness

April 22, 2014
Posted by

Jeff Wilson

Former All Black wing Jeff Wilson says it would be a foolish decision to opt for a Super Rugby competition without teams from South Africa.

This comes after Wilson’s former team-mate, Andrew Mehrtens, last week called for a competition without South Africa.

Mehrtens said the travel and time difference between New Zealand and South Africa are problematic. He feels it would be better for all concerned if the Kiwis and Aussies were to play within their time zone and include teams from the Pacific Islands and Japan.

Mehrtens wants South Africa to join teams from the UK and Europe and form their own competition.

However, Wilson begs to differ from Mehrtens, and expressed his opinion via a column on the Stuff.co.nz website.

“This talk of moving away from South Africa in Super Rugby is madness. This is the best international competition outside of Test rugby and it would be foolhardy to mess with its essential formula,” wrote Wilson.

“The three countries each provide a different type of football, and I’d be reluctant to change anything that precluded those clashes of styles.

“This franchise competition prepares our players and coaches very, very well for the next level of the game – and that should not be under-estimated.

“It’s not only the clashes of style – the mental and physical challenge you face on any given week is huge.

“I don’t buy that the distance factor should force South Africa to play elsewhere. Travel is part and parcel of international sport and not a contributing factor for poor performance.”

Wilson also said the competition prepares their players well for when they face the Springboks later in the year.

He said the challenge that South Africa presents is constant and if there’s “one team New Zealanders get nervous about playing, particularly in the republic, it’s the Springboks”.

Wilson, 40, played 60 Tests for the All Blacks between 1993 and 2002. He also represented New Zealand in cricket.

Post to Twitter Post to Facebook Post to MySpace

4 Comments

  1. avatar Cheetah Glory says:
    April 22nd, 2014 at 12:48 pm

    Wilson comes from a rugby point of view which makes sense. Mehrtens comes from a commercial point of view and also makes good points.

    SA needs to prepare for both scenarios.

  2. avatar Jacques(Bunny) says:
    April 22nd, 2014 at 1:09 pm

    SA will win more than what they will lose if they go to Europe and NZ and Aus will lose more than what they will gain, and I am not talking about the money factor.

  3. avatar DavidS says:
    April 22nd, 2014 at 1:11 pm

    @Cheetah Glory:

    Mehrtens has however not given sufficient thoght to his appproach.

  4. avatar out wide says:
    April 23rd, 2014 at 2:19 am

    Ha ha – well spoken “Goldie”. Wilson reflects the thinking of the average kiwi rugby supporter. To them, professional rugby players are highly paid athletes who travel with all the luxuries of Business class and stay in hotels not available to the average joe. They must just suck up the rigours of travel and get on with playing the game. The travel fatigue excuse for losing died its natural death a long time ago.

    NZ, SA and Oz will stay dominating 1 -3 in world rugby pecking order while we still have the feeder players competing in the tough Superugby comp.

Switch to our mobile site