Home Opinion Super Rugby too much, too long and requires too much travel

Super Rugby too much, too long and requires too much travel


It would cheer me up no end if Super Rugby was chopped in half and the South African teams booted out, writes PETER LAMPP for Rugby Heaven

It has to be the worst-designed competition on the planet – too long and across too many time zones.

The current playoffs have shown that, with the Hurricanes having to fly to South Africa and the Chiefs having to zap back from Cape Town to play in the Christchurch swamp.

It’s crazy that Super Rugby not only starts in February, but constricts the window for all of our NPC teams, such as the Manawatu Turbos, to play, let alone play each other.

The length of Super Rugby affects our All Blacks. Week in week out they slog away against the other New Zealand teams and are bruised bruisers when it comes to the June tests.

Two games between each of the NZ teams should be enough, but no, it was three this year, all of them brutal affairs.

Meanwhile, the Aussie teams were so hopeless that their Wallabies players will be fresh for the upcoming Rugby Championship.

Manawatu has a stack of Super players. But having trained their guts out since late last year, they often return to Manawatu either mentally or physically tuckered out.

We saw that each year with wing Asaeli Tikoirotuma and last year with Crusaders prop Michael Alaalatoa.

By this stage of the season, NPC coaches are just praying their players get through uninjured.

This competition started as the South Pacific Championship –from 1986 to 1990 – before it became the Super 6 in 1992. The South Pacific was organised by the New South Wales Rugby Union and the tougher rugby against New Zealand teams really lifted the Aussie sides.

Maybe it’s time New Zealand cut itself adrift again.

Super 10 came along in 1993 in the days before players were (officially) paid, and even then they played only four pool games and a final. Then it became Super 12 from 1996, when the Crusaders finished dead last, Super Rugby from 2011 with 15 teams, and now there are 18 teams with those in the playoffs slogging through 17 games.

Next year, the bright sparks want to cut it back to 15 teams, but sides such as the Western Force are proving as stubborn to dislodge as they were on the field as Australia’s most improved team.

Tonga and Western Samoa were part of Super 10, but were flicked when Super 12 came along because they wouldn’t have had the dollars.

New Zealand had five teams in their conference this year, whereas the top qualifiers, the Lions from Johannesburg, had four teams and the other three weren’t much chop.

The Brumbies had the cheek to be disappointed they didn’t progress to the semifinals despite finishing 22 competition points behind the Hurricanes, who had to travel to frigid Canberra for their troubles last weekend.

The Blues are constantly disparaged and yet only three other teams outside New Zealand scored more competition points.

OBM deserved their triumph

Knockout rugby can be cruel, but few among the estimated 2500 to 3000 who watched Saturday’s Manawatu club final begrudged third qualifiers Old Boys-Marist (OBM) their first win with a hyphen and a farewell for coach Reece Robinson.

They did what the Canes did at Canberra and lifted their forwards grunt in the second half.

Poor Kia Toa. If they reach next year’s Hankins final, they might need a white-coated psychologist to deliver the team talk after losing their fourth consecutive final.

Turbos coach Jeremy Cotter will have been pleased to see his Turbos men among the OBMs leading the charge – Fraser Armstrong, Hunter Prescott and Ambrose Curtis – as well as big Fijian second-five Kameli Kuruyabaki, fullback Luther Hirini, who the Turbos signed out of Feilding High School, and veteran lock Chris Long. So pleased was Long afterwards he toasted his wife and said, “see you Tuesday”.

With playoffs, it’s about timing your run. Round-robin winners Varsity will justifiably claim they were the most consistent team all season. They twice beat each of the other three top-four teams over the two rounds of regular play, but that will soon be forgotten after they pitch-poled against Kias in the semi.

Varsity will recall they too won the Hankins as third qualifiers last season by toppling OBM with a last-second penalty and then Kia Toa in the final with a late try.

Such a waste

Malakai Fekitoa might well have stayed in New Zealand if the All Blacks selectors had reassured him.

Instead, when the squad to face the British and Irish Lions was named, he was omitted. That was similar to when the Blues ignored him and, feeling rejected, he scarpered to the Highlanders in 2014.

In the All Blacks’ hour of need, he was called up for the third Lions test. But that was too late and now he’s off to Toulon in the prime of his career as a 25 year old.

He could be erratic and tackle high, but he was an experienced midfield attacker with 25 tests to his name.

 By – Stuff

Leave a comment


  1. Please kick us out and play against the Island boys and the Aussies, you do us no favorites to have us in this SuperShit.

    You complain about the travel of the NZ teams in the play-offs, we have been doing it for years MATE!!

    Wish SANZAAR will kick us out so that you can have your island tournament

  2. I think calm heads are needed. Both SA and NZ are far the better for it in playing in the same comp. the one major problem is the travel, and its hammering SA teams and players much worse.

    I think they’ve got to do something. Maybe have the comp once every 2 years. Or else one season the teams play it in SA, the next in Oz/nz. There must be solutions.

  3. @cab: Cab there are so many solutions to our problems but the idiots at SANZAAR do not care….

    They care only about money and how much they can get in….that the reason that Cheetahs and Kings are going out but we have the Sunpuppies, Rebels and Force that are worst than those two teams.

    The Kings had exactly the same amount of years in the competition than these sunpuppies with them getting better with six wins against the two of the puppies. That is one short from the Jaguares who has almost a full international setup.

    From the Aussie teams only the Brumbies at 34 ended higher than the Kings
    The Reds, Waratahs and Rebels have all ended lower than the Cheetahs even.

    If we wanted to kick out three sides we should have done so with the Aussies not two SA teams.

    But in my mind I still want a two tier competition

    Tier one: Four top NZ teams, Four Top SA teams, Three Aussie teams and the Jaguares.
    That gives you your Super 12

    Then you have Tier 2

    Sunpuppies, the other two SA teams, other two Aussie teams, two Island team and if you want an USA team.

    Promotion regulation if you want at the end of the season.Lowest team out highest team in.

    This will give you each team playing each other every year, with the top four going to semi’s and non of this conference shit.

  4. Yeah couldn’t agree more Jacques, sounds like bullshit to me.

    I think a lot of it is Ozzie interference, that john on Neil full too big for his boots. Think Oz reckon they call the shots, but they don’t, everyone got to be treated equally for this thing to work.

  5. I hope SANSAAR reads this and takes it to heart. Kick us and our money out. Let NZ fight on its own.

Comments are closed.